Featured Categories

Cooking so fun
Eat fruits & vegetables to be healthy
Enjoy the best of a good beer
For someone sweet like you
The best breakfast to start the day
With deli you can stop a while for a tasty snack

Compare Foods can proudly claim to be a supermarket

We offer more than just the basics of what you would expect to find at a grocery store. Beyond the standard departments every shopper needs, we also offer ways to shop organic, for prepared meals and salads, easy meals, daily specials and so much more.

At the end of the day we strive to make it simple as could be to take care of what you need. As a matter of fact, we feel a true supermarket makes sure you, as our customers, take care of tasks you normally wouldn’t even get around to doing.

Our employees are trained to help answer any questions our customers may have regarding our products. We value our customers and try to accomodate to their needs as much as possible. Our unparalled products and our loyal customers make Pick and Save Supermarket a great place. We are happy to serve our customers and want to make sure that they have a great shopping experience while in our store.

Our Services

Senior citizien discount 10%

Wednesday only! Excluding beer, cigarettes & sales items

It pay to recycle

Bottle redemption machine

Free Delivery

With add'l $50.00 purchase or more

Open 7 Days a week

Monday-Saturday. 7.30Am to 9:00Pm
Sunday. 7.30Am to 8:00Pm

We gladly accept

Visa, MasterCard, NYCE, QUEST, We now have Western unnion & ATM Machine


Lets reduce the carbon footprint in our neighborhood. City Going Digital

Current Weekly Sales Flyer

The most amazing sales in the area!

Instagram Super Sale!

Follow us on Instagram

Contact Info

Straight Path Wyandanch Ny 11798

Open 7 Days a Week!
Mon-Sat. 7:30Am to 9:00Pm ° Sun:7.30Am to 8:00Pm

+1 (631) 254 1400

Job Application

Personal Details

Contact Details



Previous Employment

Terms of service

Terms of Service - Store Policy

All returns, refunds or exchanges must be accompanied by proper sale receipt. Perishable items returns must be claimed within 24 Hours of purchase with original receipt. 10% Discount only apply for regular priced items. Weekly Sale Items, Manager Sales, Alcoholic Beverages, Hot Food Platter or Meat Plans do not apply for 10% Discount. No roller skating or bicycle riding inside the store. No pets allowed. We reserve the right to check all bags. Senior Citizen Discount apply to people 65 years of age or over with proper ID. Rain Checks are available for out of stock weekly sale items.

Contact Form

We’d like to know what our customers think, Feel free to write us.